one4review | On 16, Sep 2026

Experience a whisky tasting with a social, high-energy twist. A group of strangers descended into the depths of Mother Superior in Leith, emerging two hours later filled with laughter, good cheer and a surprising amount of new whisky knowledge.

The event centres around tables of four competing in a whisky-themed pub quiz, with each break bringing a tasting of one of three spectacular whiskies. With an array of prizes on offer, ranging from restaurant vouchers to premium whisky bottles, there is plenty to play for, but the atmosphere remains refreshingly unpretentious. It’s competitive without ever becoming intimidating, and the emphasis is firmly on having a good time.

This is the perfect experience for those who prefer the comfort of a traditional pub over the formality of a private members’ club. While there is certainly a time and place for exclusivity, this event is designed for those moments when you want to keep things relaxed, informal and fun. It manages to make whisky feel accessible rather than stuffy.

The hosts are a pair of local whisky experts and landlords, both clearly eager to share their passion for whisky. They possess a wealth of knowledge but never make you feel inadequate for not knowing it already. No prior whisky experience is required, and the balance between education, entertainment and competition is just right.

I had a fantastic time. I met some genuinely interesting people and learned a great deal about both the whisky-making process and Scottish culture, all while sampling premium whiskies I otherwise probably wouldn’t have had the opportunity to try.

I would particularly recommend this to anyone attending alone. I joined a group of three strangers and within minutes it felt like we’d arrived together. The quiz provides an instant social connection, and the questions are accessible enough to give complete beginners a genuine chance of winning. It really is a level playing field, which makes the whole experience considerably more enjoyable.

This is a wonderful addition to the Fringe: informative without being stuffy, competitive without being intimidating and, above all, enormous fun. Whether you’re a seasoned whisky drinker or someone who wouldn’t know a dram from a dramatised history lesson, there’s something here for you.

I hope to see The Big Fat Whisky Quiz return every year, and perhaps inspire similar events throughout Edinburgh. Five stars, and an easy recommendation.
*****
Reviewed by Mike
19.30 to 21.00
Until 30th Aug